Insurer Loses Appeals Against Two More ISDs Over Disputed Property Damage Claims

Gustine, Alto and Grapeland ISD map

Rulings: An insurance company can’t force the lawsuits filed by two ISDs over storm related property damage claims into arbitration. The Travelers Indemnity Co. v. Grapeland ISD, No. 12-22-00311-CV, issued May 10, 2023, by the Texas Twelfth Court of Appeals (Tyler) and [Travelers] v. Gustine ISD, No. 11-21-00229-CV, Issued May 25, 2023, by the Texas Eleventh Court of Appeals (Eastland).

These two appellate decisions issued this month — involving the Grapeland and Gustine districts — mirror the outcome of another state appeals court decision issued nearly a year ago involving Alto ISD (article).

The overall facts in the dispute are nearly identical in that:

Subscribers may log in to view this content. Thanks!