|

Fifth Circuit Majority: Governments Have Total Control Over Which Library Books to Buy, Keep and Remove

U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals- map of the jurisidictions of the three states - Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi
Image: Ballotpedia

U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals
Ruling: Governmental entities are the final decision makers over which books they buy, keep, or remove in their public libraries.

  • Little, et al., v. Llano County, et al., No. 23-50224 ($), May 23, 2025. Ordered “published.”
Background

The underlying litigation was filed by seven patrons of the Llano County public library system in 2022 who challenged the removal of 17 books that the plaintiffs said were motivated by political considerations.

Pending trial — which hasn’t happened yet — the judge issued a temporary injunction ordering the county to return the 17 books that were removed back to the library shelves.

The county appealed, resulting in a 2-1 majority opinion by a three-member Fifth Circuit panel modifying the injunction by allowing some, but not all, of the books to be removed from the county’s libraries.

Image: TexEd News

A majority of Fifth Circuit justices voted to reconsider the prior decision by the three-member panel, resulting in this latest decision that was decided by a 10-7 majority of justices.

Sixty-Page Majority Opinion

The 60-page majority opinion, authored by Justice Stuart Kyle Duncan (a Trump appointee), specifically overturned a 1995 Fifth Circuit decision — arising from a Louisiana lawsuit (Campbell v. St. Tammany Parish School Board) — that suggested that students could challenge the removal of a book from public school libraries.

The majority opinion dissolves the temporary injunction on a conclusion that when it comes to libraries, the public has no First Amendment “right to information.”

“Take a deep breath, everyone. No one is banning (or burning books),” Duncan wrote, adding:

“If a disappointed patron can’t find a book in the library, he can order it online, buy it from a bookstore or borrow it from a friend. All Llano County has done is what libraries have been doing for two centuries: decide which books they want in their collections.”

Dissent: “Disturbingly Flippant” and “Legally Unsound”

The seven dissenting judges called these statements from the majority “disturbingly flippant” and “legally unsound” and warned that the decision “forsakes core First Amendment principles” about the people’s right to be informed.

  • Note: Llano County previously agreed to pay former Llano County librarian Suzette Baker $250,000 to settle the wrongful termination lawsuit she filed against the county on accusations that she had been fired because she refused to pull library materials that a group of conservative activists had deemed inappropriate for children, the Austin American-Statesman recently reported.